Cards Similar to Tar Fiend

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Tar Fiend

Kemuri-Onna $0.29 Kemuri-Onna Similar effect 4B · Spirit When this creature enters, target player discards a card. Mournwhelk $0.16 Mournwhelk Similar effect 6B · Elemental When this creature enters, target player discards two cards. Sanity Gnawers $0.14 Sanity Gnawers Similar effect 1BR · Rat When this creature enters, target player discards a card at random. Skullmulcher $0.17 Skullmulcher Similar effect 4G · Elemental Devour 1 Abyssal Horror $0.31 Abyssal Horror Similar effect 4BB · Horror Flying Shrieking Grotesque $0.05 Shrieking Grotesque Similar effect 2W · Gargoyle Flying Hellhole Rats $0.42 Hellhole Rats Similar effect 2BR · Rat Haste Voices from the Void $0.05 Voices from the Void Similar effect 4B · Sorcery Domain — Target player discards a card for each basic land type among lands you control. Mind Sludge $0.13 Mind Sludge Similar effect 4B · Sorcery Target player discards a card for each Swamp you control. Rotting Rats $1.34 Rotting Rats Similar effect 1B · Zombie Rat When this creature enters, each player discards a card. Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Miasmic Mummy Similar effect 1B · Zombie Jackal When this creature enters, each player discards a card. Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Rottenheart Ghoul Similar effect 3B · Zombie When this creature dies, target player discards a card. Earsplitting Rats $0.14 Earsplitting Rats Similar effect 3B · Rat When this creature enters, each player discards a card. Mindwarper $0.28 Mindwarper Similar effect 2BB · Spirit This creature enters with three +1/+1 counters on it. Insidious Bookworms $0.14 Insidious Bookworms Similar effect B · Worm When this creature dies, you may pay {1}{B}. Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Drainpipe Vermin Similar effect B · Rat When this creature dies, you may pay {B}. Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Sibsig Icebreakers Similar effect 2B · Zombie When this creature enters, each player discards a card. Wretched Camel $0.03 Wretched Camel Similar effect 1B · Zombie Camel When this creature dies, if you control a Desert or there is a Desert card in your graveyard, tar... Sink into Takenuma $0.08 Sink into Takenuma Similar effect 3B · Arcane Sweep — Return any number of Swamps you control to their owner's hand. Marrow Chomper $0.19 Marrow Chomper Similar effect 3BG · Zombie Lizard Devour 2

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Tar Fiend

Kemuri-Onna Kemuri-Onna $0.29 Mournwhelk Mournwhelk $0.16 Sanity Gnawers Sanity Gnawers $0.14 Skullmulcher Skullmulcher $0.17 Abyssal Horror Abyssal Horror $0.31 Shrieking Grotesque Shrieking Grotesque $0.05 Hellhole Rats Hellhole Rats $0.42 Voices from the Void Voices from the Void $0.05 Mind Sludge Mind Sludge $0.13 Rotting Rats Rotting Rats $1.34 Miasmic Mummy Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Rottenheart Ghoul Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Earsplitting Rats Earsplitting Rats $0.14 Mindwarper Mindwarper $0.28 Insidious Bookworms Insidious Bookworms $0.14 Drainpipe Vermin Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Sibsig Icebreakers Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Wretched Camel Wretched Camel $0.03 Sink into Takenuma Sink into Takenuma $0.08 Marrow Chomper Marrow Chomper $0.19

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Tar Fiend

Kemuri-Onna Kemuri-Onna $0.29 Mournwhelk Mournwhelk $0.16 Sanity Gnawers Sanity Gnawers $0.14 Skullmulcher Skullmulcher $0.17 Shrieking Grotesque Shrieking Grotesque $0.05 Hellhole Rats Hellhole Rats $0.42 Voices from the Void Voices from the Void $0.05 Mind Sludge Mind Sludge $0.13 Rotting Rats Rotting Rats $1.34 Miasmic Mummy Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Rottenheart Ghoul Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Drainpipe Vermin Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Sibsig Icebreakers Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Wretched Camel Wretched Camel $0.03 Sink into Takenuma Sink into Takenuma $0.08 Marrow Chomper Marrow Chomper $0.19

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Tar Fiend

Miasmic Mummy Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Rottenheart Ghoul Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Drainpipe Vermin Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Sibsig Icebreakers Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Wretched Camel Wretched Camel $0.03

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Tar Fiend

Mournwhelk Mournwhelk $0.16 Shrieking Grotesque Shrieking Grotesque $0.05 Rotting Rats Rotting Rats $1.34 Miasmic Mummy Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Rottenheart Ghoul Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Earsplitting Rats Earsplitting Rats $0.14 Insidious Bookworms Insidious Bookworms $0.14 Drainpipe Vermin Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Sibsig Icebreakers Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Wretched Camel Wretched Camel $0.03 Sink into Takenuma Sink into Takenuma $0.08

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Tar Fiend

Kemuri-Onna Kemuri-Onna $0.29 Mournwhelk Mournwhelk $0.16 Sanity Gnawers Sanity Gnawers $0.14 Skullmulcher Skullmulcher $0.17 Abyssal Horror Abyssal Horror $0.31 Shrieking Grotesque Shrieking Grotesque $0.05 Hellhole Rats Hellhole Rats $0.42 Voices from the Void Voices from the Void $0.05 Mind Sludge Mind Sludge $0.13 Rotting Rats Rotting Rats $1.34 Miasmic Mummy Miasmic Mummy $0.09 Rottenheart Ghoul Rottenheart Ghoul $0.06 Earsplitting Rats Earsplitting Rats $0.14 Mindwarper Mindwarper $0.28 Insidious Bookworms Insidious Bookworms $0.14 Drainpipe Vermin Drainpipe Vermin $0.14 Sibsig Icebreakers Sibsig Icebreakers $0.06 Wretched Camel Wretched Camel $0.03 Sink into Takenuma Sink into Takenuma $0.08 Marrow Chomper Marrow Chomper $0.19
Tar Fiend vs Kemuri-Onna — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Removal Flying Haste Graveyard
See all top Devour cards in MTG →
All cards from Shards of Alara →
Buy Tar Fiend on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Tar Fiend