Cards Similar to Taken by Nightmares

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Taken by Nightmares

Necrotic Fumes $0.05 Necrotic Fumes Similar effect 1BB · Lesson As an additional cost to cast this spell, exile a creature you control. Dakkon, Shadow Slayer $0.63 Dakkon, Shadow Slayer Similar effect WUB · Dakkon Dakkon enters with a number of loyalty counters on him equal to the number of lands you control. Faith Unbroken $0.16 Faith Unbroken Similar effect 3W · Aura Enchant creature you control Ruinous Intrusion $0.29 Ruinous Intrusion Similar effect 3G · Instant Exile target artifact or enchantment. Gideon Blackblade $1.20 Gideon Blackblade Similar effect 1WW · Gideon During your turn, Gideon Blackblade is a 4/4 Human Soldier creature with indestructible that's st... Helvault $0.17 Helvault Similar effect 3 · Legendary Artifact {1}, {T}: Exile target creature you control. Settle Beyond Reality $0.09 Settle Beyond Reality Similar effect 4W · Sorcery Choose one or both — Cold Storage $0.70 Cold Storage Similar effect 4 · Artifact {3}: Exile target creature you control. Cloudshift $1.28 Cloudshift Similar effect W · Instant Exile target creature you control, then return that card to the battlefield under your control. Now You See Me . . . $0.05 Now You See Me . . . Similar effect W · Instant Exile target creature you control, then return it to the battlefield under its owner's control wi... Ajani Unyielding $0.45 Ajani Unyielding Similar effect 4GW · Ajani +2: Reveal the top three cards of your library. Safe Haven $0.58 Safe Haven Similar effect Land {2}, {T}: Exile target creature you control. The Windy City The Windy City Similar effect Chicago When you planeswalk here and at the beginning of your upkeep, put a flying counter on target nont... Ephemerate $5.20 Ephemerate Similar effect W · Instant Exile target creature you control, then return it to the battlefield under its owner's control. Fear of Abduction $0.08 Fear of Abduction Similar effect 4WW · Nightmare As an additional cost to cast this spell, exile a creature you control. Momentary Blink $0.21 Momentary Blink Similar effect 1W · Instant Exile target creature you control, then return it to the battlefield under its owner's control. Liberate $0.39 Liberate Similar effect 1W · Instant Exile target creature you control. Sisters of Stone Death Avatar Sisters of Stone Death Avatar Similar effect Vanguard Each creature you control must be blocked if able. Essence Flux $1.74 Essence Flux Similar effect U · Instant Exile target creature you control, then return that card to the battlefield under its owner's con... Deadly Rollick $25.03 Deadly Rollick Similar effect 3B · Instant If you control a commander, you may cast this spell without paying its mana cost.

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Taken by Nightmares

Necrotic Fumes Necrotic Fumes $0.05 Dakkon, Shadow Slayer Dakkon, Shadow Slayer $0.63 Faith Unbroken Faith Unbroken $0.16 Ruinous Intrusion Ruinous Intrusion $0.29 Gideon Blackblade Gideon Blackblade $1.20 Helvault Helvault $0.17 Settle Beyond Reality Settle Beyond Reality $0.09 Cold Storage Cold Storage $0.70 Cloudshift Cloudshift $1.28 Ajani Unyielding Ajani Unyielding $0.45 Safe Haven Safe Haven $0.58 Ephemerate Ephemerate $5.20 Fear of Abduction Fear of Abduction $0.08 Momentary Blink Momentary Blink $0.21 Liberate Liberate $0.39 Essence Flux Essence Flux $1.74 Deadly Rollick Deadly Rollick $25.03

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Taken by Nightmares

Necrotic Fumes Necrotic Fumes $0.05 Dakkon, Shadow Slayer Dakkon, Shadow Slayer $0.63 Faith Unbroken Faith Unbroken $0.16 Gideon Blackblade Gideon Blackblade $1.20 Helvault Helvault $0.17 Settle Beyond Reality Settle Beyond Reality $0.09 Cloudshift Cloudshift $1.28 Ajani Unyielding Ajani Unyielding $0.45 Safe Haven Safe Haven $0.58 Ephemerate Ephemerate $5.20 Fear of Abduction Fear of Abduction $0.08 Momentary Blink Momentary Blink $0.21 Essence Flux Essence Flux $1.74

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Taken by Nightmares

Necrotic Fumes Necrotic Fumes $0.05 Faith Unbroken Faith Unbroken $0.16 Gideon Blackblade Gideon Blackblade $1.20 Ajani Unyielding Ajani Unyielding $0.45 Fear of Abduction Fear of Abduction $0.08 Essence Flux Essence Flux $1.74

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Taken by Nightmares

Settle Beyond Reality Settle Beyond Reality $0.09 Cloudshift Cloudshift $1.28 Ephemerate Ephemerate $5.20 Momentary Blink Momentary Blink $0.21 Essence Flux Essence Flux $1.74

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Taken by Nightmares

Necrotic Fumes Necrotic Fumes $0.05 Dakkon, Shadow Slayer Dakkon, Shadow Slayer $0.63 Faith Unbroken Faith Unbroken $0.16 Ruinous Intrusion Ruinous Intrusion $0.29 Gideon Blackblade Gideon Blackblade $1.20 Helvault Helvault $0.17 Settle Beyond Reality Settle Beyond Reality $0.09 Cold Storage Cold Storage $0.70 Cloudshift Cloudshift $1.28 Ajani Unyielding Ajani Unyielding $0.45 Safe Haven Safe Haven $0.58 Ephemerate Ephemerate $5.20 Fear of Abduction Fear of Abduction $0.08 Momentary Blink Momentary Blink $0.21 Liberate Liberate $0.39 Essence Flux Essence Flux $1.74 Deadly Rollick Deadly Rollick $25.03
Taken by Nightmares vs Necrotic Fumes — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Exile Indestructible Flying
All cards from Wilds of Eldraine →
Buy Taken by Nightmares on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Taken by Nightmares