Cards Similar to Shoot the Sheriff

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Shoot the Sheriff

These 20 cards share similar roles with Shoot the Sheriff — look for other instants that fill the same slot in your deck.

Swat $0.09 Swat Removal 1BB · Instant Destroy target creature with power 2 or less. Krovikan Rot $0.17 Krovikan Rot Removal 2B · Instant Destroy target creature with power 2 or less. Fatal Push $0.88 Fatal Push Removal B · Instant Destroy target creature if it has mana value 2 or less. Long Goodbye $0.30 Long Goodbye Removal 1B · Instant This spell can't be countered. Liliana's Defeat $0.14 Liliana's Defeat Removal B · Sorcery Destroy target black creature or black planeswalker. Cruel Cut Cruel Cut Removal 1B · Instant Destroy target creature with power 2 or less. Spin Out $0.05 Spin Out Removal 1BB · Instant Destroy target creature or Vehicle. Bitter Triumph $1.46 Bitter Triumph Removal 1B · Instant As an additional cost to cast this spell, discard a card or pay 3 life. May of the Machine May of the Machine Removal 2B · Sorcery Destroy target creature or planeswalker. Bone Shredder $0.14 Bone Shredder Removal 2B · Phyrexian Minion Flying Hand of Death $0.15 Hand of Death Removal 2B · Sorcery Destroy target nonblack creature. Poison the Cup $0.21 Poison the Cup Removal 1BB · Instant Destroy target creature. Wasp of the Bitter End $0.19 Wasp of the Bitter End Removal 1B · Insect Horror Flying Come Back Wrong $0.31 Come Back Wrong Removal 2B · Sorcery Destroy target creature. Asphyxiate $0.07 Asphyxiate Removal 1BB · Sorcery Destroy target untapped creature. Assassin's Blade $0.32 Assassin's Blade Removal 1B · Instant Cast this spell only during the declare attackers step and only if you've been attacked this step. Crumbling Ashes $45.04 Crumbling Ashes Removal 1B · Enchantment At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target creature with a -1/-1 counter on it. Cradle to Grave $0.08 Cradle to Grave Removal 1B · Instant Destroy target nonblack creature that entered this turn. Seal of Doom $0.15 Seal of Doom Removal 2B · Enchantment Sacrifice this enchantment: Destroy target nonblack creature. Royal Assassin $0.39 Royal Assassin Removal 1BB · Human Assassin {T}: Destroy target tapped creature.

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Swat Swat $0.09 Buy
Krovikan Rot Krovikan Rot $0.17 Buy
Fatal Push Fatal Push $0.88 Buy
Long Goodbye Long Goodbye $0.30 Buy
Liliana's Defeat Liliana's Defeat $0.14 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Bitter Triumph Bitter Triumph $1.46 Buy
Bone Shredder Bone Shredder $0.14 Buy
Hand of Death Hand of Death $0.15 Buy
Poison the Cup Poison the Cup $0.21 Buy
Wasp of the Bitter End Wasp of the Bitter End $0.19 Buy
Come Back Wrong Come Back Wrong $0.31 Buy
Asphyxiate Asphyxiate $0.07 Buy
Assassin's Blade Assassin's Blade $0.32 Buy
Crumbling Ashes Crumbling Ashes $45.04 Buy
Cradle to Grave Cradle to Grave $0.08 Buy
Seal of Doom Seal of Doom $0.15 Buy
Royal Assassin Royal Assassin $0.39 Buy

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Krovikan Rot Krovikan Rot $0.17 Buy
Fatal Push Fatal Push $0.88 Buy
Long Goodbye Long Goodbye $0.30 Buy
Liliana's Defeat Liliana's Defeat $0.14 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Bitter Triumph Bitter Triumph $1.46 Buy
Bone Shredder Bone Shredder $0.14 Buy
Poison the Cup Poison the Cup $0.21 Buy
Wasp of the Bitter End Wasp of the Bitter End $0.19 Buy
Come Back Wrong Come Back Wrong $0.31 Buy
Asphyxiate Asphyxiate $0.07 Buy
Crumbling Ashes Crumbling Ashes $45.04 Buy
Cradle to Grave Cradle to Grave $0.08 Buy
Seal of Doom Seal of Doom $0.15 Buy
Royal Assassin Royal Assassin $0.39 Buy

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Fatal Push Fatal Push $0.88 Buy
Long Goodbye Long Goodbye $0.30 Buy
Liliana's Defeat Liliana's Defeat $0.14 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Bitter Triumph Bitter Triumph $1.46 Buy
Poison the Cup Poison the Cup $0.21 Buy
Wasp of the Bitter End Wasp of the Bitter End $0.19 Buy
Come Back Wrong Come Back Wrong $0.31 Buy
Asphyxiate Asphyxiate $0.07 Buy

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Long Goodbye Long Goodbye $0.30 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Bitter Triumph Bitter Triumph $1.46 Buy
Come Back Wrong Come Back Wrong $0.31 Buy

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Swat Swat $0.09 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Hand of Death Hand of Death $0.15 Buy
Asphyxiate Asphyxiate $0.07 Buy
Cradle to Grave Cradle to Grave $0.08 Buy
Seal of Doom Seal of Doom $0.15 Buy

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Shoot the Sheriff

Swat Swat $0.09 Buy
Krovikan Rot Krovikan Rot $0.17 Buy
Fatal Push Fatal Push $0.88 Buy
Long Goodbye Long Goodbye $0.30 Buy
Liliana's Defeat Liliana's Defeat $0.14 Buy
Spin Out Spin Out $0.05 Buy
Bitter Triumph Bitter Triumph $1.46 Buy
Bone Shredder Bone Shredder $0.14 Buy
Hand of Death Hand of Death $0.15 Buy
Poison the Cup Poison the Cup $0.21 Buy
Wasp of the Bitter End Wasp of the Bitter End $0.19 Buy
Come Back Wrong Come Back Wrong $0.31 Buy
Asphyxiate Asphyxiate $0.07 Buy
Assassin's Blade Assassin's Blade $0.32 Buy
Crumbling Ashes Crumbling Ashes $45.04 Buy
Cradle to Grave Cradle to Grave $0.08 Buy
Seal of Doom Seal of Doom $0.15 Buy
Royal Assassin Royal Assassin $0.39 Buy
Shoot the Sheriff vs Swat — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Removal Flying
All cards from Outlaws of Thunder Junction →
Buy Shoot the Sheriff on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Shoot the Sheriff