Cards Similar to Preacher

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Preacher

Old Man of the Sea Old Man of the Sea Similar effect 1UU · Djinn You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Callous Oppressor $1.57 Callous Oppressor Similar effect 1UU · Octopus You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Seasinger Seasinger Similar effect 1UU · Merfolk When you control no Islands, sacrifice this creature. Sand Squid $0.58 Sand Squid Similar effect 3U · Squid Beast Islandwalk Whip Vine $0.12 Whip Vine Similar effect 2G · Plant Wall Defender; reach Giant Oyster $0.24 Giant Oyster Similar effect 2UU · Oyster You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Pearlspear Courier $0.08 Pearlspear Courier Similar effect 2W · Human Soldier You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Willow Satyr Willow Satyr Similar effect 2GG · Satyr You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Ghosthelm Courier $0.11 Ghosthelm Courier Similar effect 2U · Human Wizard You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Rust Tick $0.15 Rust Tick Similar effect 3 · Insect You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Thalakos Dreamsower $0.25 Thalakos Dreamsower Similar effect 2U · Thalakos Wizard Shadow Everglove Courier $0.10 Everglove Courier Similar effect 2G · Elf You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Mole Worms $0.22 Mole Worms Similar effect 2B · Worm You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Frightshroud Courier $0.15 Frightshroud Courier Similar effect 2B · Zombie You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Mana Leech $0.20 Mana Leech Similar effect 2B · Leech You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Vedalken Shackles $6.56 Vedalken Shackles Similar effect 3 · Artifact You may choose not to untap this artifact during your untap step. Phyrexian Gremlins $1.04 Phyrexian Gremlins Similar effect 2B · Phyrexian Gremlin You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Flamestick Courier $0.10 Flamestick Courier Similar effect 2R · Goblin You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Hedge Whisperer $0.06 Hedge Whisperer Similar effect G · Elf Druid Detective You may choose not to untap this creature during your untap step. Helm of Possession $4.62 Helm of Possession Similar effect 4 · Artifact You may choose not to untap this artifact during your untap step.

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Preacher

Old Man of the Sea Old Man of the Sea Callous Oppressor Callous Oppressor $1.57 Seasinger Seasinger Sand Squid Sand Squid $0.58 Whip Vine Whip Vine $0.12 Giant Oyster Giant Oyster $0.24 Pearlspear Courier Pearlspear Courier $0.08 Willow Satyr Willow Satyr Ghosthelm Courier Ghosthelm Courier $0.11 Rust Tick Rust Tick $0.15 Thalakos Dreamsower Thalakos Dreamsower $0.25 Everglove Courier Everglove Courier $0.10 Mole Worms Mole Worms $0.22 Frightshroud Courier Frightshroud Courier $0.15 Mana Leech Mana Leech $0.20 Vedalken Shackles Vedalken Shackles $6.56 Phyrexian Gremlins Phyrexian Gremlins $1.04 Flamestick Courier Flamestick Courier $0.10 Hedge Whisperer Hedge Whisperer $0.06 Helm of Possession Helm of Possession $4.62

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Preacher

Giant Oyster Giant Oyster $0.24 Rust Tick Rust Tick $0.15 Vedalken Shackles Vedalken Shackles $6.56 Hedge Whisperer Hedge Whisperer $0.06

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Preacher

Whip Vine Whip Vine $0.12 Phyrexian Gremlins Phyrexian Gremlins $1.04

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Preacher

Old Man of the Sea Old Man of the Sea Callous Oppressor Callous Oppressor $1.57 Seasinger Seasinger Sand Squid Sand Squid $0.58 Whip Vine Whip Vine $0.12 Giant Oyster Giant Oyster $0.24 Pearlspear Courier Pearlspear Courier $0.08 Willow Satyr Willow Satyr Ghosthelm Courier Ghosthelm Courier $0.11 Rust Tick Rust Tick $0.15 Thalakos Dreamsower Thalakos Dreamsower $0.25 Everglove Courier Everglove Courier $0.10 Mole Worms Mole Worms $0.22 Frightshroud Courier Frightshroud Courier $0.15 Mana Leech Mana Leech $0.20 Vedalken Shackles Vedalken Shackles $6.56 Phyrexian Gremlins Phyrexian Gremlins $1.04 Flamestick Courier Flamestick Courier $0.10 Hedge Whisperer Hedge Whisperer $0.06 Helm of Possession Helm of Possession $4.62
Preacher vs Old Man of the Sea — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Reach Removal Defender
See all top Reach cards in MTG →
All cards from The Dark →
Buy Preacher on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Preacher