Cards Similar to Pit Keeper

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Pit Keeper

Oversold Cemetery $1.98 Oversold Cemetery Similar effect 1B · Enchantment At the beginning of your upkeep, if you have four or more creature cards in your graveyard, you m... Cadaver Imp $0.05 Cadaver Imp Similar effect 1BB · Imp Flying Gravedigger $0.13 Gravedigger Similar effect 3B · Zombie When this creature enters, you may return target creature card from your graveyard to your hand. Graveshifter $0.25 Graveshifter Similar effect 3B · Shapeshifter Changeling Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Midnight Scavengers Similar effect 4B · Human Rogue When this creature enters, you may return target creature card with mana value 3 or less from you... Moriok Scavenger $0.05 Moriok Scavenger Similar effect 3B · Human Rogue When this creature enters, you may return target artifact creature card from your graveyard to yo... Auramancer $0.19 Auramancer Similar effect 2W · Human Wizard When this creature enters, you may return target enchantment card from your graveyard to your hand. Scrivener Scrivener Similar effect 4U · Human Wizard When this creature enters, you may return target instant card from your graveyard to your hand. Strongarm Thug $0.19 Strongarm Thug Similar effect 2B · Human Mercenary When this creature enters, you may return target Mercenary card from your graveyard to your hand. Corpse Cur $0.26 Corpse Cur Similar effect 4 · Phyrexian Dog Infect Master Skald $0.05 Master Skald Similar effect 4W · Dwarf Warrior When this creature enters, you may exile a creature card from your graveyard. Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Ironclad Slayer Similar effect 2W · Human Warrior When this creature enters, you may return target Aura or Equipment card from your graveyard to yo... Treasure Hunter $0.35 Treasure Hunter Similar effect 2W · Human When this creature enters, you may return target artifact card from your graveyard to your hand. Stoic Builder $0.04 Stoic Builder Similar effect 2G · Human When this creature enters, you may return target land card from your graveyard to your hand. Eternal Witness $1.48 Eternal Witness Similar effect 1GG · Human Shaman When this creature enters, you may return target card from your graveyard to your hand. Cartographer $0.15 Cartographer Similar effect 2G · Human When this creature enters, you may return target land card from your graveyard to your hand. Kishla Trawlers $0.09 Kishla Trawlers Similar effect 2U · Human Citizen When this creature enters, you may exile a creature card from your graveyard. Undead Butler $0.35 Undead Butler Similar effect 1B · Zombie When this creature enters, mill three cards. Daring Archaeologist $0.10 Daring Archaeologist Similar effect 3W · Human Artificer When this creature enters, you may return target artifact card from your graveyard to your hand. Halimar Tidecaller $0.14 Halimar Tidecaller Similar effect 2U · Human Wizard Ally When this creature enters, you may return target card with awaken from your graveyard to your hand.

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Oversold Cemetery Oversold Cemetery $1.98 Cadaver Imp Cadaver Imp $0.05 Gravedigger Gravedigger $0.13 Graveshifter Graveshifter $0.25 Midnight Scavengers Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Moriok Scavenger Moriok Scavenger $0.05 Auramancer Auramancer $0.19 Scrivener Scrivener Strongarm Thug Strongarm Thug $0.19 Corpse Cur Corpse Cur $0.26 Master Skald Master Skald $0.05 Ironclad Slayer Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Treasure Hunter Treasure Hunter $0.35 Stoic Builder Stoic Builder $0.04 Eternal Witness Eternal Witness $1.48 Cartographer Cartographer $0.15 Kishla Trawlers Kishla Trawlers $0.09 Undead Butler Undead Butler $0.35 Daring Archaeologist Daring Archaeologist $0.10 Halimar Tidecaller Halimar Tidecaller $0.14

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Cadaver Imp Cadaver Imp $0.05 Gravedigger Gravedigger $0.13 Graveshifter Graveshifter $0.25 Midnight Scavengers Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Moriok Scavenger Moriok Scavenger $0.05 Auramancer Auramancer $0.19 Corpse Cur Corpse Cur $0.26 Master Skald Master Skald $0.05 Ironclad Slayer Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Treasure Hunter Treasure Hunter $0.35 Stoic Builder Stoic Builder $0.04 Eternal Witness Eternal Witness $1.48 Kishla Trawlers Kishla Trawlers $0.09 Undead Butler Undead Butler $0.35 Daring Archaeologist Daring Archaeologist $0.10 Halimar Tidecaller Halimar Tidecaller $0.14

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Gravedigger Gravedigger $0.13 Graveshifter Graveshifter $0.25 Midnight Scavengers Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Auramancer Auramancer $0.19 Master Skald Master Skald $0.05 Ironclad Slayer Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Stoic Builder Stoic Builder $0.04 Kishla Trawlers Kishla Trawlers $0.09 Undead Butler Undead Butler $0.35 Daring Archaeologist Daring Archaeologist $0.10 Halimar Tidecaller Halimar Tidecaller $0.14

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Graveshifter Graveshifter $0.25 Kishla Trawlers Kishla Trawlers $0.09

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Cadaver Imp Cadaver Imp $0.05 Gravedigger Gravedigger $0.13 Midnight Scavengers Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Moriok Scavenger Moriok Scavenger $0.05 Auramancer Auramancer $0.19 Scrivener Scrivener Corpse Cur Corpse Cur $0.26 Master Skald Master Skald $0.05 Ironclad Slayer Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Stoic Builder Stoic Builder $0.04 Cartographer Cartographer $0.15

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Pit Keeper

Oversold Cemetery Oversold Cemetery $1.98 Cadaver Imp Cadaver Imp $0.05 Gravedigger Gravedigger $0.13 Graveshifter Graveshifter $0.25 Midnight Scavengers Midnight Scavengers $0.11 Moriok Scavenger Moriok Scavenger $0.05 Auramancer Auramancer $0.19 Scrivener Scrivener Strongarm Thug Strongarm Thug $0.19 Corpse Cur Corpse Cur $0.26 Master Skald Master Skald $0.05 Ironclad Slayer Ironclad Slayer $0.17 Treasure Hunter Treasure Hunter $0.35 Stoic Builder Stoic Builder $0.04 Eternal Witness Eternal Witness $1.48 Cartographer Cartographer $0.15 Kishla Trawlers Kishla Trawlers $0.09 Undead Butler Undead Butler $0.35 Daring Archaeologist Daring Archaeologist $0.10 Halimar Tidecaller Halimar Tidecaller $0.14
Pit Keeper vs Oversold Cemetery — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Bounce Graveyard Flying Artifact Mill
All cards from Time Spiral Remastered →
Buy Pit Keeper on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Pit Keeper