Cards Similar to Nightmare

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Nightmare

These 20 cards share similar roles with Nightmare — look for other creatures that fill the same slot in your deck.

Squelching Leeches $0.14 Squelching Leeches Similar effect 2BB · Leech Squelching Leeches's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps you control. Korlash, Heir to Blackblade $3.27 Korlash, Heir to Blackblade Similar effect 2BB · Zombie Warrior Korlash's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps you control. Swampbenders $1.01 Swampbenders Similar effect 4GG · Human Druid Ally Swampbenders's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps on the battlefield. Battle Squadron $0.50 Battle Squadron Similar effect 3RR · Goblin Flying Silverwing Squadron $0.36 Silverwing Squadron Similar effect 5W · Human Knight Flying, vigilance Soramaro, First to Dream $0.38 Soramaro, First to Dream Similar effect 4UU · Spirit Flying Seraph of the Masses $0.70 Seraph of the Masses Similar effect 5WW · Angel Convoke Pack Rat $4.63 Pack Rat Similar effect 1B · Rat Pack Rat's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Rats you control. Dakkon Blackblade Dakkon Blackblade Similar effect 2WUUB · Human Warrior Dakkon Blackblade's power and toughness are each equal to the number of lands you control. Crowd of Cinders $0.15 Crowd of Cinders Similar effect 3B · Elemental Fear Drift of the Dead Drift of the Dead Similar effect 3B · Wall Defender Faerie Swarm $1.04 Faerie Swarm Similar effect 3U · Faerie Flying Broodstar $0.85 Broodstar Similar effect 8UU · Beast Affinity for artifacts Phyrexian Broodstar Phyrexian Broodstar Similar effect 6UU · Phyrexian Beast Affinity for Phyrexians Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn $0.81 Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn Similar effect Spirit Warlock // Legendary Enchantment — Aura Flying, lifelink, protection from Vampires Kalonian Twingrove $0.57 Kalonian Twingrove Similar effect 5G · Treefolk Warrior Kalonian Twingrove's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Forests you control. Tishana, Voice of Thunder $0.34 Tishana, Voice of Thunder Similar effect 5GU · Merfolk Shaman Tishana's power and toughness are each equal to the number of cards in your hand. Rubblehulk $0.16 Rubblehulk Similar effect 4RG · Elemental Rubblehulk's power and toughness are each equal to the number of lands you control. Geist-Honored Monk $0.31 Geist-Honored Monk Similar effect 3WW · Human Monk Vigilance Convention Maro $0.21 Convention Maro Similar effect 1G2/U2/R · Elemental Gamer Whenever you cast a spell that [CHOICE A], create a green Elemental creature token named Maro wit...

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Nightmare

Squelching Leeches Squelching Leeches $0.14 Buy
Korlash, Heir to Blackblade Korlash, Heir to Blackblade $3.27 Buy
Swampbenders Swampbenders $1.01 Buy
Battle Squadron Battle Squadron $0.50 Buy
Silverwing Squadron Silverwing Squadron $0.36 Buy
Soramaro, First to Dream Soramaro, First to Dream $0.38 Buy
Seraph of the Masses Seraph of the Masses $0.70 Buy
Pack Rat Pack Rat $4.63 Buy
Dakkon Blackblade Dakkon Blackblade Buy
Crowd of Cinders Crowd of Cinders $0.15 Buy
Drift of the Dead Drift of the Dead Buy
Faerie Swarm Faerie Swarm $1.04 Buy
Broodstar Broodstar $0.85 Buy
Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn $0.81 Buy
Kalonian Twingrove Kalonian Twingrove $0.57 Buy
Tishana, Voice of Thunder Tishana, Voice of Thunder $0.34 Buy
Rubblehulk Rubblehulk $0.16 Buy
Geist-Honored Monk Geist-Honored Monk $0.31 Buy

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Nightmare

Squelching Leeches Squelching Leeches $0.14 Buy
Korlash, Heir to Blackblade Korlash, Heir to Blackblade $3.27 Buy
Silverwing Squadron Silverwing Squadron $0.36 Buy
Soramaro, First to Dream Soramaro, First to Dream $0.38 Buy
Seraph of the Masses Seraph of the Masses $0.70 Buy
Pack Rat Pack Rat $4.63 Buy
Crowd of Cinders Crowd of Cinders $0.15 Buy
Faerie Swarm Faerie Swarm $1.04 Buy
Broodstar Broodstar $0.85 Buy
Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn $0.81 Buy
Kalonian Twingrove Kalonian Twingrove $0.57 Buy
Tishana, Voice of Thunder Tishana, Voice of Thunder $0.34 Buy
Rubblehulk Rubblehulk $0.16 Buy
Geist-Honored Monk Geist-Honored Monk $0.31 Buy

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Nightmare

Squelching Leeches Squelching Leeches $0.14 Buy
Silverwing Squadron Silverwing Squadron $0.36 Buy
Seraph of the Masses Seraph of the Masses $0.70 Buy
Pack Rat Pack Rat $4.63 Buy
Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn $0.81 Buy
Kalonian Twingrove Kalonian Twingrove $0.57 Buy
Tishana, Voice of Thunder Tishana, Voice of Thunder $0.34 Buy
Rubblehulk Rubblehulk $0.16 Buy

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Nightmare

Squelching Leeches Squelching Leeches $0.14 Buy
Korlash, Heir to Blackblade Korlash, Heir to Blackblade $3.27 Buy
Swampbenders Swampbenders $1.01 Buy
Battle Squadron Battle Squadron $0.50 Buy
Silverwing Squadron Silverwing Squadron $0.36 Buy
Soramaro, First to Dream Soramaro, First to Dream $0.38 Buy
Seraph of the Masses Seraph of the Masses $0.70 Buy
Pack Rat Pack Rat $4.63 Buy
Dakkon Blackblade Dakkon Blackblade Buy
Crowd of Cinders Crowd of Cinders $0.15 Buy
Drift of the Dead Drift of the Dead Buy
Faerie Swarm Faerie Swarm $1.04 Buy
Broodstar Broodstar $0.85 Buy
Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr // Katilda's Rising Dawn $0.81 Buy
Kalonian Twingrove Kalonian Twingrove $0.57 Buy
Tishana, Voice of Thunder Tishana, Voice of Thunder $0.34 Buy
Rubblehulk Rubblehulk $0.16 Buy
Geist-Honored Monk Geist-Honored Monk $0.31 Buy
Nightmare vs Squelching Leeches — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Flying Reach Vigilance Defender Lifelink
See all top Flying cards in MTG →
All cards from Unlimited Edition →
Buy Nightmare on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Nightmare