Cards Similar to Melancholy

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Melancholy

Thirst $0.12 Thirst Similar effect 2U · Aura Enchant creature Paralyze Paralyze Similar effect B · Aura Enchant creature Sleeping Potion $0.17 Sleeping Potion Similar effect 1U · Aura Enchant creature Sleep Magic $0.10 Sleep Magic Similar effect U · Aura Enchant creature Mystic Restraints $0.13 Mystic Restraints Similar effect 2UU · Aura Flash Waterknot $0.11 Waterknot Similar effect 1UU · Aura Enchant creature Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Sleep Paralysis Similar effect 3U · Aura Enchant creature Venarian Gold $0.45 Venarian Gold Similar effect XUU · Aura Enchant creature Starlight Snare $0.14 Starlight Snare Similar effect 2U · Aura Enchant creature Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Singing Bell Strike Similar effect 1U · Aura Enchant creature Charmed Sleep $0.09 Charmed Sleep Similar effect 1UU · Aura Enchant creature Motion Sickness $0.04 Motion Sickness Similar effect 3U · Aura Enchant creature Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Similar effect 1U · Aura Enchant creature Capture Sphere $0.06 Capture Sphere Similar effect 3U · Aura Flash Containment Protocol $0.39 Containment Protocol Similar effect 2U · Aura Enchant creature Claustrophobia $0.11 Claustrophobia Similar effect 1UU · Aura Enchant creature Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Dramatic Accusation Similar effect 2U · Aura Enchant creature Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Ringing Strike Mastery Similar effect U · Aura Enchant creature Tangle Kelp $0.91 Tangle Kelp Similar effect U · Aura Enchant creature Bitter Chill $0.08 Bitter Chill Similar effect 1U · Aura Enchant creature

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Thirst Thirst $0.12 Paralyze Paralyze Sleeping Potion Sleeping Potion $0.17 Sleep Magic Sleep Magic $0.10 Mystic Restraints Mystic Restraints $0.13 Waterknot Waterknot $0.11 Sleep Paralysis Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Venarian Gold Venarian Gold $0.45 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Singing Bell Strike Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Motion Sickness Motion Sickness $0.04 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Capture Sphere Capture Sphere $0.06 Containment Protocol Containment Protocol $0.39 Claustrophobia Claustrophobia $0.11 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Tangle Kelp Tangle Kelp $0.91 Bitter Chill Bitter Chill $0.08

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Sleep Magic Sleep Magic $0.10 Mystic Restraints Mystic Restraints $0.13 Waterknot Waterknot $0.11 Sleep Paralysis Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Singing Bell Strike Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Capture Sphere Capture Sphere $0.06 Claustrophobia Claustrophobia $0.11 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Bitter Chill Bitter Chill $0.08

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Sleep Magic Sleep Magic $0.10 Waterknot Waterknot $0.11 Sleep Paralysis Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Singing Bell Strike Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Capture Sphere Capture Sphere $0.06 Claustrophobia Claustrophobia $0.11 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Bitter Chill Bitter Chill $0.08

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Sleep Magic Sleep Magic $0.10 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Bitter Chill Bitter Chill $0.08

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Thirst Thirst $0.12 Paralyze Paralyze Sleeping Potion Sleeping Potion $0.17 Mystic Restraints Mystic Restraints $0.13 Waterknot Waterknot $0.11 Sleep Paralysis Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Venarian Gold Venarian Gold $0.45 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Singing Bell Strike Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Motion Sickness Motion Sickness $0.04 Capture Sphere Capture Sphere $0.06 Containment Protocol Containment Protocol $0.39 Claustrophobia Claustrophobia $0.11 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Melancholy

Thirst Thirst $0.12 Paralyze Paralyze Sleeping Potion Sleeping Potion $0.17 Sleep Magic Sleep Magic $0.10 Mystic Restraints Mystic Restraints $0.13 Waterknot Waterknot $0.11 Sleep Paralysis Sleep Paralysis $0.04 Venarian Gold Venarian Gold $0.45 Starlight Snare Starlight Snare $0.14 Singing Bell Strike Singing Bell Strike $0.09 Charmed Sleep Charmed Sleep $0.09 Motion Sickness Motion Sickness $0.04 Stay Hidden, Stay Silent Stay Hidden, Stay Silent $0.06 Capture Sphere Capture Sphere $0.06 Containment Protocol Containment Protocol $0.39 Claustrophobia Claustrophobia $0.11 Dramatic Accusation Dramatic Accusation $0.04 Ringing Strike Mastery Ringing Strike Mastery $0.08 Tangle Kelp Tangle Kelp $0.91 Bitter Chill Bitter Chill $0.08
Melancholy vs Thirst — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Removal Flash
All cards from Planar Chaos →
Buy Melancholy on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Melancholy