Cards Similar to Make a Wish

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Make a Wish

Reap the Past $0.37 Reap the Past Similar effect XRG · Sorcery Return X cards at random from your graveyard to your hand. The Deck of Many Things $7.13 The Deck of Many Things Similar effect 5 · Legendary Artifact {2}, {T}: Roll a d20 and subtract the number of cards in your hand. Another Chance $0.16 Another Chance Similar effect 2B · Instant You may mill two cards. Does Machines $0.79 Does Machines Similar effect 1U · Class When this Class enters, mill two cards, draw two cards, then discard two cards. Trash Bin $0.13 Trash Bin Similar effect Attraction Visit — Mill two cards, then return a card at random from your graveyard to your hand. Tilling Treefolk $0.27 Tilling Treefolk Similar effect 2G · Treefolk Druid When this creature enters, you may return up to two target land cards from your graveyard to your... The Mending of Dominaria $0.36 The Mending of Dominaria Similar effect 3GG · Saga I, II — Mill two cards, then you may return a creature card from your graveyard to your hand. Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Pull Through the Weft Similar effect 3GG · Sorcery Return up to two target nonland permanent cards from your graveyard to your hand, then return up ... Restock $0.11 Restock Similar effect 3GG · Sorcery Return two target cards from your graveyard to your hand. Woodland Sleuth $0.06 Woodland Sleuth Similar effect 3G · Human Scout Morbid — When this creature enters, if a creature died this turn, return a creature card at rando... Rite of Renewal $0.12 Rite of Renewal Similar effect 3G · Sorcery Return up to two target permanent cards from your graveyard to your hand. Regenesis $0.05 Regenesis Similar effect 3GG · Instant Return up to two target permanent cards from your graveyard to your hand. Mythos of Brokkos $0.33 Mythos of Brokkos Similar effect 2GG · Sorcery If {U}{B} was spent to cast this spell, search your library for a card, put that card into your g... Seeds of Renewal $0.24 Seeds of Renewal Similar effect 6G · Sorcery Undaunted Acolyte of Affliction $0.08 Acolyte of Affliction Similar effect 2BG · Human Cleric When this creature enters, mill two cards, then you may return a permanent card from your graveya... Old One Eye $3.56 Old One Eye Similar effect 5G · Tyranid Trample Peerless Recycling $0.22 Peerless Recycling Similar effect 1G · Instant Gift a card Moldgraf Monstrosity $0.29 Moldgraf Monstrosity Similar effect 4GGG · Insect Trample Nyx Weaver $0.23 Nyx Weaver Similar effect 1BG · Spider Reach Viconia, Drow Apostate $0.10 Viconia, Drow Apostate Similar effect 2B · Elf Cleric At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are four or more creature cards in your graveyard, retu...

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

Reap the Past Reap the Past $0.37 The Deck of Many Things The Deck of Many Things $7.13 Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Does Machines Does Machines $0.79 Trash Bin Trash Bin $0.13 Tilling Treefolk Tilling Treefolk $0.27 The Mending of Dominaria The Mending of Dominaria $0.36 Pull Through the Weft Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Restock Restock $0.11 Woodland Sleuth Woodland Sleuth $0.06 Rite of Renewal Rite of Renewal $0.12 Regenesis Regenesis $0.05 Mythos of Brokkos Mythos of Brokkos $0.33 Seeds of Renewal Seeds of Renewal $0.24 Acolyte of Affliction Acolyte of Affliction $0.08 Old One Eye Old One Eye $3.56 Peerless Recycling Peerless Recycling $0.22 Moldgraf Monstrosity Moldgraf Monstrosity $0.29 Nyx Weaver Nyx Weaver $0.23 Viconia, Drow Apostate Viconia, Drow Apostate $0.10

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

Reap the Past Reap the Past $0.37 The Deck of Many Things The Deck of Many Things $7.13 Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Does Machines Does Machines $0.79 Tilling Treefolk Tilling Treefolk $0.27 The Mending of Dominaria The Mending of Dominaria $0.36 Pull Through the Weft Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Restock Restock $0.11 Woodland Sleuth Woodland Sleuth $0.06 Rite of Renewal Rite of Renewal $0.12 Regenesis Regenesis $0.05 Mythos of Brokkos Mythos of Brokkos $0.33 Acolyte of Affliction Acolyte of Affliction $0.08 Peerless Recycling Peerless Recycling $0.22 Moldgraf Monstrosity Moldgraf Monstrosity $0.29 Nyx Weaver Nyx Weaver $0.23

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

The Deck of Many Things The Deck of Many Things $7.13 Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Does Machines Does Machines $0.79 The Mending of Dominaria The Mending of Dominaria $0.36 Pull Through the Weft Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Restock Restock $0.11 Rite of Renewal Rite of Renewal $0.12 Regenesis Regenesis $0.05 Mythos of Brokkos Mythos of Brokkos $0.33 Acolyte of Affliction Acolyte of Affliction $0.08 Peerless Recycling Peerless Recycling $0.22 Nyx Weaver Nyx Weaver $0.23

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Does Machines Does Machines $0.79 Pull Through the Weft Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Rite of Renewal Rite of Renewal $0.12 Peerless Recycling Peerless Recycling $0.22

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Tilling Treefolk Tilling Treefolk $0.27 Woodland Sleuth Woodland Sleuth $0.06

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Make a Wish

Reap the Past Reap the Past $0.37 The Deck of Many Things The Deck of Many Things $7.13 Another Chance Another Chance $0.16 Does Machines Does Machines $0.79 Tilling Treefolk Tilling Treefolk $0.27 The Mending of Dominaria The Mending of Dominaria $0.36 Pull Through the Weft Pull Through the Weft $0.16 Restock Restock $0.11 Woodland Sleuth Woodland Sleuth $0.06 Rite of Renewal Rite of Renewal $0.12 Regenesis Regenesis $0.05 Mythos of Brokkos Mythos of Brokkos $0.33 Seeds of Renewal Seeds of Renewal $0.24 Acolyte of Affliction Acolyte of Affliction $0.08 Old One Eye Old One Eye $3.56 Peerless Recycling Peerless Recycling $0.22 Moldgraf Monstrosity Moldgraf Monstrosity $0.29 Nyx Weaver Nyx Weaver $0.23 Viconia, Drow Apostate Viconia, Drow Apostate $0.10
Make a Wish vs Reap the Past — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Graveyard Mill Cantrip Tutor Trample
All cards from Innistrad →
Buy Make a Wish on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Make a Wish