Cards Similar to Custodi Soulcaller

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Custodi Soulcaller

Unforgiving One $0.11 Unforgiving One Similar effect 2B · Spirit Menace Timely Hordemate $0.03 Timely Hordemate Similar effect 3W · Human Warrior Raid — When this creature enters, if you attacked this turn, return target creature card with man... Bishop of Rebirth $0.38 Bishop of Rebirth Similar effect 3WW · Vampire Cleric Vigilance Venerable Warsinger $0.29 Venerable Warsinger Similar effect 1RW · Spirit Cleric Vigilance, trample Meanders Guide $0.20 Meanders Guide Similar effect 2W · Merfolk Scout Whenever this creature attacks, you may tap another untapped Merfolk you control. Guardian Scalelord $5.37 Guardian Scalelord Similar effect 4W · Dragon Backup 1 Devoted Crop-Mate $0.06 Devoted Crop-Mate Similar effect 2W · Human Warrior You may exert this creature as it attacks. Necropanther $0.15 Necropanther Similar effect 1WB · Cat Nightmare Mutate {2}{W/B}{W/B} Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Tethmos High Priest Similar effect 2W · Cat Cleric Heroic — Whenever you cast a spell that targets this creature, return target creature card with m... Reaping Willow $0.26 Reaping Willow Similar effect 1W/BW/BW/B · Treefolk Cleric Lifelink Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Yathan Roadwatcher Similar effect 1WBG · Human Scout When this creature enters, if you cast it, mill four cards. Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Similar effect 1BR · Human Warrior First strike Celestine, the Living Saint $26.89 Celestine, the Living Saint Similar effect 4W · Human Warrior Flying, lifelink Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Astelli Reclaimer Similar effect 3WW · Angel Warrior Flying Driver of the Dead $0.09 Driver of the Dead Similar effect 3B · Vampire When this creature dies, return target creature card with mana value 2 or less from your graveyar... Order of Whiteclay $0.36 Order of Whiteclay Similar effect 1WW · Kithkin Cleric {1}{W}{W}, {Q}: Return target creature card with mana value 3 or less from your graveyard to the ... Redemption Choir $0.26 Redemption Choir Similar effect 2WW · Vampire Cleric Lifelink Brotherhood Outcast $0.26 Brotherhood Outcast Similar effect 2W · Human Soldier When this creature enters, choose one — Emptiness $2.45 Emptiness Similar effect 4W/BW/B · Elemental Incarnation When this creature enters, if {W}{W} was spent to cast it, return target creature card with mana ... Rodolf Duskbringer $4.80 Rodolf Duskbringer Similar effect 5B · Vampire Angel Flying, deathtouch, lifelink

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Unforgiving One Unforgiving One $0.11 Timely Hordemate Timely Hordemate $0.03 Bishop of Rebirth Bishop of Rebirth $0.38 Venerable Warsinger Venerable Warsinger $0.29 Meanders Guide Meanders Guide $0.20 Guardian Scalelord Guardian Scalelord $5.37 Devoted Crop-Mate Devoted Crop-Mate $0.06 Necropanther Necropanther $0.15 Tethmos High Priest Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Reaping Willow Reaping Willow $0.26 Yathan Roadwatcher Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Celestine, the Living Saint Celestine, the Living Saint $26.89 Astelli Reclaimer Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09 Order of Whiteclay Order of Whiteclay $0.36 Redemption Choir Redemption Choir $0.26 Brotherhood Outcast Brotherhood Outcast $0.26 Emptiness Emptiness $2.45 Rodolf Duskbringer Rodolf Duskbringer $4.80

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Unforgiving One Unforgiving One $0.11 Timely Hordemate Timely Hordemate $0.03 Bishop of Rebirth Bishop of Rebirth $0.38 Venerable Warsinger Venerable Warsinger $0.29 Meanders Guide Meanders Guide $0.20 Devoted Crop-Mate Devoted Crop-Mate $0.06 Necropanther Necropanther $0.15 Tethmos High Priest Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Reaping Willow Reaping Willow $0.26 Yathan Roadwatcher Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Astelli Reclaimer Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09 Order of Whiteclay Order of Whiteclay $0.36 Emptiness Emptiness $2.45

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Unforgiving One Unforgiving One $0.11 Timely Hordemate Timely Hordemate $0.03 Bishop of Rebirth Bishop of Rebirth $0.38 Venerable Warsinger Venerable Warsinger $0.29 Meanders Guide Meanders Guide $0.20 Devoted Crop-Mate Devoted Crop-Mate $0.06 Necropanther Necropanther $0.15 Tethmos High Priest Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Reaping Willow Reaping Willow $0.26 Yathan Roadwatcher Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Astelli Reclaimer Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09 Emptiness Emptiness $2.45

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Meanders Guide Meanders Guide $0.20 Reaping Willow Reaping Willow $0.26 Yathan Roadwatcher Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Astelli Reclaimer Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09 Emptiness Emptiness $2.45

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Tethmos High Priest Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Custodi Soulcaller

Unforgiving One Unforgiving One $0.11 Timely Hordemate Timely Hordemate $0.03 Bishop of Rebirth Bishop of Rebirth $0.38 Venerable Warsinger Venerable Warsinger $0.29 Meanders Guide Meanders Guide $0.20 Guardian Scalelord Guardian Scalelord $5.37 Devoted Crop-Mate Devoted Crop-Mate $0.06 Necropanther Necropanther $0.15 Tethmos High Priest Tethmos High Priest $0.09 Reaping Willow Reaping Willow $0.26 Yathan Roadwatcher Yathan Roadwatcher $0.16 Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate $1.71 Celestine, the Living Saint Celestine, the Living Saint $26.89 Astelli Reclaimer Astelli Reclaimer $0.26 Driver of the Dead Driver of the Dead $0.09 Order of Whiteclay Order of Whiteclay $0.36 Redemption Choir Redemption Choir $0.26 Brotherhood Outcast Brotherhood Outcast $0.26 Emptiness Emptiness $2.45 Rodolf Duskbringer Rodolf Duskbringer $4.80
Custodi Soulcaller vs Unforgiving One — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Bounce Anthem Graveyard Menace Vigilance
All cards from Conspiracy: Take the Crown →
Buy Custodi Soulcaller on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Custodi Soulcaller