Cards Similar to Collective Nightmare

20 cards with similar effects or strategies — View Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Deal Gone Bad Similar effect 3B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Wither and Bloom $0.10 Wither and Bloom Similar effect 1B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Strangling Spores $0.04 Strangling Spores Similar effect 3B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Tragic Fall $0.05 Tragic Fall Similar effect 1B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Urge to Feed $0.26 Urge to Feed Similar effect BB · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Smokespew Invoker $0.11 Smokespew Invoker Similar effect 2B · Zombie Mutant {7}{B}: Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Last Gasp $0.07 Last Gasp Similar effect 1B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Ichor Slick $0.06 Ichor Slick Similar effect 2B · Sorcery Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. A-Deal Gone Bad A-Deal Gone Bad Similar effect 3B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Wasteland Strangler $0.16 Wasteland Strangler Similar effect 2B · Eldrazi Processor Devoid Aphetto Exterminator $0.17 Aphetto Exterminator Similar effect 2B · Human Wizard Morph {3}{B} Candy Grapple $0.14 Candy Grapple Similar effect 1B · Instant Bargain Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Dubious Delicacy Similar effect 2B · Food Flash Clear the Stage $0.10 Clear the Stage Similar effect 4B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Caustic Exhale $0.12 Caustic Exhale Similar effect B · Instant As an additional cost to cast this spell, behold a Dragon or pay {1}. Ulcerate $0.12 Ulcerate Similar effect B · Instant Target creature gets -3/-3 until end of turn. Weigh Down $0.08 Weigh Down Similar effect B · Sorcery As an additional cost to cast this spell, exile a creature card from your graveyard. Bog Naughty $0.11 Bog Naughty Similar effect 3BB · Faerie Flying Slaughterhouse Bouncer $0.05 Slaughterhouse Bouncer Similar effect 4B · Ogre Warrior Hellbent — When this creature dies, if you have no cards in hand, target creature gets -3/-3 unti... Silumgar Butcher $0.05 Silumgar Butcher Similar effect 4B · Zombie Djinn Exploit

Alternatives by Format

Commander-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Wither and Bloom Wither and Bloom $0.10 Strangling Spores Strangling Spores $0.04 Tragic Fall Tragic Fall $0.05 Urge to Feed Urge to Feed $0.26 Smokespew Invoker Smokespew Invoker $0.11 Last Gasp Last Gasp $0.07 Ichor Slick Ichor Slick $0.06 Wasteland Strangler Wasteland Strangler $0.16 Aphetto Exterminator Aphetto Exterminator $0.17 Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Dubious Delicacy Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Clear the Stage Clear the Stage $0.10 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12 Ulcerate Ulcerate $0.12 Weigh Down Weigh Down $0.08 Bog Naughty Bog Naughty $0.11 Slaughterhouse Bouncer Slaughterhouse Bouncer $0.05 Silumgar Butcher Silumgar Butcher $0.05

Modern-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Wither and Bloom Wither and Bloom $0.10 Strangling Spores Strangling Spores $0.04 Tragic Fall Tragic Fall $0.05 Urge to Feed Urge to Feed $0.26 Last Gasp Last Gasp $0.07 Ichor Slick Ichor Slick $0.06 Wasteland Strangler Wasteland Strangler $0.16 Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Dubious Delicacy Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Clear the Stage Clear the Stage $0.10 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12 Ulcerate Ulcerate $0.12 Weigh Down Weigh Down $0.08 Bog Naughty Bog Naughty $0.11 Slaughterhouse Bouncer Slaughterhouse Bouncer $0.05 Silumgar Butcher Silumgar Butcher $0.05

Pioneer-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Strangling Spores Strangling Spores $0.04 Wasteland Strangler Wasteland Strangler $0.16 Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Dubious Delicacy Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Clear the Stage Clear the Stage $0.10 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12 Ulcerate Ulcerate $0.12 Weigh Down Weigh Down $0.08 Bog Naughty Bog Naughty $0.11 Silumgar Butcher Silumgar Butcher $0.05

Standard-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Dubious Delicacy Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12

Pauper-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Wither and Bloom Wither and Bloom $0.10 Strangling Spores Strangling Spores $0.04 Tragic Fall Tragic Fall $0.05 Smokespew Invoker Smokespew Invoker $0.11 Last Gasp Last Gasp $0.07 Ichor Slick Ichor Slick $0.06 Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12 Weigh Down Weigh Down $0.08 Slaughterhouse Bouncer Slaughterhouse Bouncer $0.05 Silumgar Butcher Silumgar Butcher $0.05

Legacy-Legal Alternatives to Collective Nightmare

Deal Gone Bad Deal Gone Bad $0.08 Wither and Bloom Wither and Bloom $0.10 Strangling Spores Strangling Spores $0.04 Tragic Fall Tragic Fall $0.05 Urge to Feed Urge to Feed $0.26 Smokespew Invoker Smokespew Invoker $0.11 Last Gasp Last Gasp $0.07 Ichor Slick Ichor Slick $0.06 Wasteland Strangler Wasteland Strangler $0.16 Aphetto Exterminator Aphetto Exterminator $0.17 Candy Grapple Candy Grapple $0.14 Dubious Delicacy Dubious Delicacy $0.12 Clear the Stage Clear the Stage $0.10 Caustic Exhale Caustic Exhale $0.12 Ulcerate Ulcerate $0.12 Weigh Down Weigh Down $0.08 Bog Naughty Bog Naughty $0.11 Slaughterhouse Bouncer Slaughterhouse Bouncer $0.05 Silumgar Butcher Silumgar Butcher $0.05
Collective Nightmare vs Deal Gone Bad — side-by-side comparison →
📚 Learn more:
Flash Graveyard Flying
See all top Convoke cards in MTG →
All cards from March of the Machine →
Buy Collective Nightmare on TCGPlayer Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate and TCGPlayer affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.

← Back to Collective Nightmare